The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
TheBest2011-1000x50

Freedom of "Speech"

I've been waiting for someone to point to Hollywood as a convenient scapegoat for the Arizona shootings.. So far,  so good, however, as nobody has yet resorted to that familiar punching bag, so popular with both Democrats and Republicans whenever something awful happens that raises too many tough questions.

Besides, whether he intended to or not, Ricky Gervais took enough pot shots at Hollywood bigwigs during the Golden Globes to satisfy the most diehard Culture Warrior. In fact, Conservatives have pretty much embraced him (thanks to Stephen Brophy for bringing this to my attention) as one of their own, though apparently none of them stayed tuned to the broadcast through to the closing credits to hear Gervais's final comment, "And thank you God for making me an atheist.

So, perhaps civility may reign briefly in politics. It will never take hold, though, in Hollywood during Oscar season. Compared to Academy Award campaigns, political campaigns are as toothless as "The King's Speech." For some have suggested that the story has been considerably whitewashed. An anonymous source sent an e-mail to blogger Scott Feinberg reminding people that King George VI, though played brilliantly by Colin Firth, was perhaps a bit of an anti-Semite and Nazi appeaser. Aamong other  things, it seems he endorsed Britain's policy of barring Jewish refugees from relocating to Palestine, instead returning them to Germany. None of which is mentioned in the film.

Of course, the aggrieved parties are insisting that these reports originate with the competition in categories in which "Speech" is strongest, most notably Best Actor, where Firth is a leading candidate. Their claims are no doubt true, but then  so, it seems, are the claims about George VI.  But I find this germane only insofar as had the filmmakers actually included this troubled aspect of their story the film would have been far richer psychologically and dramatically. On the other hand had they actually delved into such ambiguous and troubling depths instead of grinding out the non-controversial pabulum that seems to delight Academy members when it comes to biopics of this kind, it probably wouldn't get any Oscar attention. Or even made in the first place.

And finally, it's ironic that the aggrieved studio releasing "The King's Speech" is the Weinstein Brothers since they were rumored to be the ones behind similar "smear campaigns" against "A Beautiful Mind" in 2002 and "The Hurt Locker" last year. I guess turnabout is fair play.

| More

1 Comments

  • Tom McKenna said:

    Peter-

    How is the Arizona shooting and the blame Hollywood HASN'T received, Ricky Gervais' respect from conservatives for his Golden Globe performance, and the alleged whitewashing of The King's Speech and the just dessert's it may signify for the Weinstein brothers connected?  This is a scattered article indeed.

    I occasionally agree with some of your reviews, but the seemingly obligatory Frankfurt School-inspired bourgious Marxist ranting that inevitably dominates your writing makes you sound like you should be writing for the Worker's Vanguard.  I'm fully aware that the Phoenix would like to think itself to hip for such a comparison as the hipsters who dominate much of that readership have long graduated from being parent's-basement dwelling communists to Phoenix-reading, parent's-basement dwelling cynics.  So please, be more cynical (and I wouldn't say this to anyone else on the staff believe me).

    This article resembles Jared Loughner's youtube ramblings.

    tssk, tssk...What would Henry Jenkins say...  

    January 20, 2011 6:33 PM

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Articles

TJI_012811_BSCF_list
Boston Phoenix
Marwencol and Jafar Panahi star at Boston Society of Film Critics awards
Published 1/22/2011 by PETER KEOUGH
Critical Acclaim Dept.

Freedom of "Speech"
Boston Phoenix
Freedom of "Speech"
Published 1/20/2011 by Peter Keough
I've been waiting for someone to point to Hollywood as a convenient scapegoat for the Arizona shootings.. So far,  so good, however, as nobody has...

more by Peter Keough
See these films: Do the Right Thing & Taxi Driver at the MFA | February 04, 2011
See this film: Pink Flamingos at the Coolidge | February 04, 2011
Review: On the Bowery | February 04, 2011
See this film: Vertigo at the MFA | February 03, 2011
"The King's Speech" reigns; "Marwencol" rules | January 31, 2011

 See all articles by: Peter Keough

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
2012 GOP Presidential Rankings, Updated! - Tim Pawlenty: "His new book positions him perfectly for the Iowa conservatives, and beyond."...

By gahanson on 02-03-2011 in Talking Politics

PODCAST: Finally my VCR is back in style [MP3] - VCR's can be had for as little as 5 bucks at Goodwill stores and VHS tapes for as little as 50 cents...

By alanwk on 02-01-2011 in Laser Orgy

FREE D-Tension EP (featuring "Why I Fuck Girls" and some serious tracks too) - D-Tension , Lyrics Born and Kabir LIVE @ Brighton Music Hall (formerly Harper's Ferry) on Friday 2-4...

By Rap Promoter Person on 02-01-2011 in On The Download

DOJ turns on Turner, First Amendment - I've seen a number of articles complaining that Turner received a too-harsh penalty for not being apologetic...

By Jim-84302 on 01-26-2011 in Phlog

DOJ turns on Turner, First Amendment - Carmen M. Ortiz AG described public corruption as a violation of civil rights! Will she act and prosecute...

By tired_of_corruption on 01-26-2011 in Phlog

Latest Comments from Outside The Frame
Most Viewed
New Donna Tartt in the Works
Paperback Roundup
How is Booky Formed?
Featured Event: Rachel Polonsky
15 Morbidly Depressing Novels
50% Off Amazon, 75% Off Guilt
Chris Adrian Sets the Record Straight
Most Viewed from Outside The Frame
Search Blogs
 
Outside The Frame Archives
Friday, February 04, 2011  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group