The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
the best boston and national bands, best music poll, boston phoenix

Lisa Nesselson -- Cannes report #2: more Von Trier


What's the world coming to when a filmmaker can't joke about the Nazis and the Final Solution during a Cannes press conference? Lars Von Trier is a Dane and Denmark's decidedly non-Jewish king put on a yellow star during the war, bravely defying the Nazis. Does this offer residual protection for inane rambling by depression-prone provocateurs who make movies in the 21st century?  Nah -- but Von Trier is a Nazi like Britney Spears is an intellectual. And besides, Lars was quite clear that he's NOT in favor of World War II although he thinks Hitler provided the opportunities Albert Speer needed to bloom as an architect -- and who could in good faith argue with that assertion?

Von Trier dug himself into a semantic hole by reflecting on his own ethnic and cultural identity, in response to a question from a journalist. For years he believed himself to be a Jew and felt fine and dandy about that -- although Von Trier alluded to Jewishness as a "hierarchical" state of being. I took this to mean that his Jewish credentials might have been the equivalent of one of the less coveted badges here at the Festival, the ones whose recipients have to wait in line for a long time with no guarantee they'll be admitted while being forced to watch higher ranking journalists sashay up the steps ahead of them.

Von Trier's actresses -- Kirstin Dunst on his left and Charlotte Gainsbourg on his right -- looked on in shifting amusement and dismay as Lars offered up the news flash that Adolph Hitler wasn't a particularly good person but that didn't mean the Fuhrer -- like, say, Mel Gibson -- is completely undeserving of sympathy. (In related Cannes news, Jodie Foster's "The Beaver," starring Gibson, was rather well received in its Out of Competition slot. Foster


expressed her friendship for Gibson and her gratitude for his performance, which she says she knows he's "extremely proud of." As well he should be.) Dunst -- whose character displays a variation on the clinical depression with which Gibson's character in "The Beaver" is afflicted -- seemed to have less patience than Gainsbourg for their director's scatter-brained pronouncements.


Two years ago Gainsbourg couldn't say enough good things about the process of working with Lars on "Antichrist." She probably has a better mental tuning fork for when he's serious or not


than, say, the average person reading an out-of-context wire service story.

Although he threw in two playfully low-blow digs at the Chosen People-status of Suzanne Bier (a countrywoman whose "A Better World" recently picked up a Foreign Language Oscar), the best clue to Von Trier's true feelings about Jews and Nazis was when he seemed to realize that he was in a room full of international press whose English wasn't necessarily fluent, prompting him to wonder aloud "How do I get out of this sentence?"

Rest assured, he didn't come out in favor of the Shoah or announce that Anne Frank had it coming.  He seemed to be saying in a joking manner that when he learned that not only is he not Jewish but his family has German roots, he felt he "got" where Hitler was coming from, through some sort of osmosis. Of course, Hitler was Austrian. But so was Mozart.  And so is Arnold Schwarzenegger.  But Mozart was never in the movies -- not the real Mozart, anyway. Hey! This specious rambling is kind of fun!  Let's cast it in stone and see if we can get a scandal going.  'Von Trier Is A Nazi' probably won't have the staying power of 'Polanski Is A Child Molester' on a double bill with 'Woody Allen Is A Child Molester' but let's throw virtual ink at it and see if it sticks.

Next thing you know, they'll be pulling prominent Frenchmen off airplanes for allegedly forcing themselves on female hotel personnel in Manhattan.

As a purely parenthetical aside, Von Trier's "Melancholia," which is, like, the movie he brought to Cannes to, like, totally compete in the Competition is flat-out terrific to watch.  The opening reel is as majestic as any given frame in Terrence Malick's "The Tree of Life." In "Melancholia," a planet ten times bigger than Earth


is headed this way. Perhaps Von Trier got so caught up in his work that he forgot we're all still orbiting around the sun.  For had the world truly ended after the film's premiere (immediately prior to the press conference), you would, like, totally not be reading this because, like Hitler and Mozart, you'd be cosmic dust.

EDITOR'S NOTE: Since Lisa posted this report, the Cannes Film Festival declared Von Trier "persona non grata, with effect immediately," for his remarks. Therefore he is effectively ejected, but his  film "Melancholia," remains in the festival and is still qualified for all appropriate awards.

| More


  • MrGamma said:

    I don't know the guy, and I consider myself tactless and crass, unwittingly.

    But Lars looks like a guy who thought being controversial was a way to be funny. So maybe he should stick to film-making and leave the comedy for the sharp wits and fast tongues.

    May 19, 2011 9:38 PM
  • Joe said:

    You should know more about the guy. Great filmmaker without a doubt.

    May 19, 2011 11:20 PM
  • Rebecca said:

    It's been clear for ages that Von Trier is not over-endowed with social skills and has a very, erm, unusual sense of humor. His misguided comments at Cannes were hardly on a par with John Galliano's recent behavior - or even Mel Gibson's. The fest administrators over-reacted, IMO.

    May 20, 2011 12:44 PM

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
Related Articles

cannes list
Boston Phoenix
Reichs and wrongs on the Croisette
Published 5/27/2011 by LISA NESSELSON
Cannes we all just get along?

Lisa Nesselson -- Cannes report #3: Trier today, gone tomorrow
Boston Phoenix
Lisa Nesselson -- Cannes report #3: Trier today, gone tomorrow
Published 5/21/2011 by Peter Keough
 A THOUGHT FOR TODAY (cited on A-Word-A-Day by Anu Garg): "It is well to know something of the manners of various peoples, in order more...

more by Peter Keough
Attend this film festival [comedy] event: Ben Stiller's All-Star Comedy Roundtable at the Nantucket International Film Festival | June 25, 2011
Attend this film event: 6th Annual Can't Stop the Serenity at the Coolidge | June 24, 2011
The 13th Annual Provincetown International Film Festival | June 24, 2011
Review: The Last Mountain | June 24, 2011
See this film: Hobo with a Shotgun at the Coolidge | June 23, 2011

 See all articles by: Peter Keough

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
Meet the Mayor: J.P. Licks (Brigham Circle) - mayor collins, if you enjoy the subtle flavor of squash, unseasoned, then you should definitely try the...

By vince petryk on 06-23-2011 in Phlog

Tea Party scuffles with immigrant activists at Secure Communities forum in Chelsea - Motorboat towing or simply trailering over the United states of <a>Fast...

By feenIgnisse on 06-22-2011 in Phlog

[q&a] Times New Viking keyboardist Beth Murphy on the rapture, lazy "lo-fi," and genre labels - greetings everyone, only desire to speak "howdy", aspire to pay out quite a few nice point...

By frozen_dreaded_moon_ on 06-22-2011 in On The Download

Fenway Park pulls concert permits for Sept. 8-10; Is Pearl Jam headed to Yawkey Way? - Herald did some digging, hearing it's Dropkick Murphys and Mighty Mighty Bosstones. Yawn.

By Michael Marotta on 06-21-2011 in On The Download

Gears of War 3: Female Character Added, Game Ruined - wow you guys truly are retarded women are not allowed on the front lines of war because they arnt physically...

By sean on 06-21-2011 in Laser Orgy

Latest Comments from Outside The Frame
Most Viewed
Hemingway Suicide Anniversary Ignored
Self-Published Book Captures Reviewer's Attention
Richard Russo chosen for One City, One Story
[awesome video alert] Spirit Kid "The Wrong Kind Of Money"
[q&a] Times New Viking keyboardist Beth Murphy on the rapture, lazy "lo-fi," and genre labels
Tickets on-sale alert: Ellie Goulding, Peter, Bjorn & John, James Blake, Slightly Stoopid + Shwayze, and more
[mp3] The Fatal Flaw "Narrow Hours" + release party Friday @ TT The Bear's
Most Viewed from Outside The Frame
Search Blogs
Outside The Frame Archives
Thursday, June 23, 2011  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group