The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

Afghanistan: 10 years of war

Artist and critic Greg Cook confronts the experience
By EDITORIAL  |  October 6, 2011


October 7, 2001. Military jets slice through the skies of Afghanistan, marking the beginning of what has evolved into the longest war in American history.

The sorties began 27 days after 9/11, and were followed by a ground invasion of NATO troops. In reality it was — and still is — an American operation, notably assisted with forces from Great Britain. Although a number of allies lent a morale-boosting symbolic presence, that has since melted away.

At the time, the idea seemed clear cut: destroy Al Qaeda, roust their Taliban enablers, establish a secular civil government to replace the Taliban's medieval-minded Islamist fundamentalists, and nudge Afghanistan into modernity.

In a fit of misplaced optimism, our serially incompetent president, George W. Bush, declared "Mission accomplished" on May 1, 2003.

Today, that seems a long time ago.

The United States has been fighting in Afghanistan for 10 years. Al Qaeda as an Afghan presence has been eradicated, although it has established itself elsewhere — most notably in Yemen. Osama bin Laden was killed earlier this year in a daring raid by Navy SEALs. The Taliban, however, remain a fluid and potent force inside Afghanistan and boldly operate from bases within Pakistan, an incompatible ally at best. As for the secular government sponsored by the United States, it is a wobbly gang of thieves with little purchase on popular support.


It was easier to explain why the United States invaded than to justify why we remain.

The simplest and most potent explanation is that conservatives would excrete a red, white, and blue brick if Barack Obama did what he should have done when his order to kill bin Laden was successful: declared victory and ordered the troops home.

With the US in the midst of a slow-motion nervous breakdown, as it has been for at least the past two years, the political price of facing reality is — it seems — just too high. The fear of losing Afghanistan has long been a paralyzing force in national politics. Never mind that it is not ours to lose, any more than it was there to be subdued by the Soviet Union at the zenith of its power, or tamed by England in the days when Britannia governed more of the planet than any nation before or since.

Afghanistan illogically begat Iraq, which tangentially begat Libya. We wage perpetual war for perpetual peace. Washington wishes that the populace would just accept that. And for the most part, America has. The war has become nasty, brutish, and inexorable — a political afterthought, if even that.

Now, however, comes Greg Cook, an unlikely geopolitical rabble rouser. Cook is an artist who also writes arts criticism for the Boston and Providence editions of the Phoenix.

Cook's idea is that the best way to fight against the war is to understand it, and the best way to understand it is to eschew grand strategy, to examine Afghanistan up close and personal in all of its granularity.

His tool: social media, specifically YouTube, which hosts tens of thousands of videos made by and about servicemen and -women who have served in Afghanistan.

1  |  2  |   next >
Related: Embedded, Obama's Afghanistan promise, Just a reprieve? Unless Republican leaders learn from the past, another Iraq is in our future, More more >
  Topics: The Editorial Page , Afghanistan, War, USA,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 01/08 ]   Japanese Monster + Fat Creeps + Guilty Party + The Split  @ Church of Boston
[ 01/08 ]   "Third in Line"  @ Lily Pad
[ 01/08 ]   Three Pianos  @ Loeb Drama Center
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   HOW 'THREE STRIKES' LEGISLATION FAILS  |  January 04, 2012
    Despite evidence that "three strikes" mandatory sentencing laws don't work, are punishingly expensive for taxpayers, and make an already unfair criminal-justice system even more irrational and racist, the Massachusetts legislature seems hell-bent on enacting one.
    Pity John Boehner. By rights, as Speaker of the House of Representatives, Boehner should be considered one of Washington's most powerful leaders.
    President Barack Obama is ending George W. Bush's war.
  •   COAKLEY'S TRUE GRIT  |  December 07, 2011
    Three recent developments suggest that the worm is turning and that the criminal behavior of the nation's huge money-center banks might finally suffer something approaching real justice.  
    President Barack Obama travelled to Osawatomie, Kansas, the other day and delivered an unequivocal rebuke to current economic thinking.

 See all articles by: EDITORIAL

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed