The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures


We may scream for ice cream and go cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs, but we beat our breasts for meat, the source of perhaps our most primitive cravings. That goes double for you guys — hard-wired (and hard-bodied) as you are to relish the hunt, to harbor a bloodlust for your prey (which might otherwise become predator). But in a city as uber-civilized, health-conscious, and cramped as ours —where the buffalo don’t roam (but the veggie activists do) and even space for a proper grill is scarce — well, it’s hard out here for a carnivore. With this compilation of tips from local meat mavens, we’re just trying to make it all a little easier.

Ordering it: from butcher shops to chop-houses

Grill 23's Jay Murray
"When people come to a steak house," says Ruth’s Chris Steak House GM Domenic D’Olimpio,  "the first thing they’re going to look at is the filet. " He’s right: loin cuts are no-brainers. Your filet mignons, your T-bones, your New York strips — these are the most tender (and among the leanest) cuts, hence the easiest to prepare: the less you mess with them, the better. According to butcher Ron Savenor of Beacon Hill (and now Cambridge) institution Savenor’s, you should place your order with just two key factors in mind. The first is  bright-red color. That indicates the meat is fresh, freshly cut. Beyond that, probably the most important thing is the marbling, which dictates how well it’s going to eat. That’s the oleaginous unsaturated fat. Contrary to what the world believes, that’s actually the good cholesterol. People see marbling and they think, ‘Oh, that’s terrible,’ and it’s not. "

But wait. If the loins are so lean, won’t they have less marbling? Bingo, beef-brainiac. Tenderness, though a virtue in itself, is not synonymous with flavor. In fact, among the threads that run through our conversations with the experts, one of the most common concerns the merits of humbler cuts. Says Savenor,  "People come in and say, ‘I only eat sirloin,’ or ‘I only eat tenderloin.’ My advice is, try different cuts and different recipes." 

Jay Murray, executive chef at Grill 23, blames industry conglomerates for the loin bias —which it has been in their best interest to shape through marketing. After all, lesser-known cuts  "require more effort to produce. If they want to process 600 heads of cattle a day, they can’t be cutting you flatiron steaks." And those happen to be favorites of Murray’s:  "It’s probably the most flavorful or second most flavorful steak in the entire animal. We were trying some here one night and I thought, ‘What is that flavor?’ And then I realized it tasted like squab. It was gamey but sweet; it wasn’t livery. Of course, sometimes I just want a fatty taste explosion, and then I go for the skirt steak. With every bite you just want to sit back and go, ‘Uhh.’ "

That said, if you’re going to splurge, do it right. Former chef and current Morton’s general manager Scott Crain personally recommends the New York strip ($43),  "cooked to a perfect medium-rare, with a nice char on the outside but just unbelievably tender and flavorful on the inside." Okay, granted,  "if your thing is to have it well-done with ketchup, you’re going to get it well-done with ketchup. I’m from the South, and my dad would be number one. But the only caveat we have with guests is we say, ‘If you want it well-done, we suggest that we cook it medium-well. When it arrives, if you need for us to bring up the temperature a little more, that’s what we’ll try to do. But once it gets to well-done, it can’t go back.’"

Bonus Tip: Speaking of New York strips: the Palm’s signature Steak à la Stone ($38.50) puts a nifty twist on the straight-forward sirloin by slicing it up and serving it on toast points, smothered in peppers and onions.

Bonus Tip: Leery of a little old lamb? Don’t be. According to Smith  & Wollensky chef Tindaro LoSurdo,  "If you can get a good domestic rack of lamb, it’s very sweet. It doesn’t have so much gaminess like [those from] New Zealand."

Cooking: from seasoning to searing

Smith & Wollensky's Tindaro LoSurdo
Different cuts have different flavors, and they all require slightly different cooking methods, "  says Savenor’s Ron Savenor. For instance,  "generally the cuts that require marinating are the shoulder cuts, the most used muscles —which have a really nice flavor"  that’s only enhanced by tenderization. (Acid usually constitutes the active ingredient in a marinade, be it wine, vinegar, or citrus.) Excepting the toughest cuts, says Tindaro LoSurdo,  "I personally prefer dry rubs with roasted garlic. You can use garlic powder, onion powder, cumin if you want a little South western flair. Turmeric is always good — it gives a nice smoky kind of flavor. Paprika gives a smoky flavor, too." Meanwhile, roast the garlic "so it’s brown and soft, nice and smushy; add that to the spices, mix it all together, and then rub it on the steak. What happens when grill it is, it gets that nice, garlicky, charred flavor on the outside."

LoSurdo’s advice dovetails nicely with that of Murray, who says that  "the biggest mistake people make when cooking beef is they don’t season it enough before they cook it. It’s a myth that [pre-seasoning] dries out the meat. Here [at Grill 23], we stake our reputation on letting the meat dry out for four weeks before we serve it. So how can it hurt the meat to salt it before you cook it?"  In fact, he adds, salt  "draws the proteins to the surface, so when you give [the meat] a sear, they caramelize and lock in the flavor. If you salt it after you get a crust on it, the salt just sort of bounces around. "

Savenor, on the other hand, considers overcooking blunder number one.  "My opinion is everything should be cooked rare. Not raw, but rare." And while he recommends that novices determine desired doneness with a meat thermometer,  "personally, I like to teach ‘the poke.’... I remember watching Michael Schlow do it and thinking, ‘I’m going to get this poke thing down.’" As Savenor describes it,  if you turn your palm towards you and touch that little squishy piece of skin  "between your thumb and forefinger, you’ll have a model for the texture of rare meat. Below that, where the muscles themselves meet, that’s medium-rare." And well-done would be the outside part of your thumb, closer to your wrist.

The method applies to all meats, of course; according to LoSurdo, pork in particular may merit a poke.  "I love a pork porterhouse done medium, medium-rare. The old rule about cooking [pork] all the way through — that doesn’t necessarily have to happen anymore It’s safe now, and as with anything, if you don’t overcook it, you keep the flavor in there." (Disclaimer: don’t try pork tartare at home.) He points out that, after all, the classic pairing of pork with fruit actually  "stems from the problem of overcooking. You give pork some apple-sauce, it adds sweetness to something that’s usually dry.   Still, LoSurdo gives the duo its due.  The lingering flavor of some fruit sauces helps cut the fattiness of the pork; it rounds out the dish. Apples are always good, but I also like grilled peaches and pears."

The same goes for lamb and game. Explains LoSurdo,  "People are a little afraid of their pronounced aftertaste; what the fruit sauces tend to do is kill that lingering flavor and finish off the palate. With respect to the former,  We make a mint sauce here with orange peel. The whole lamb-mint combination was originally a Middle Eastern thing"  — take that, Anglophiles—  "and they do complement each other very well."  Regarding less familiar, hence more intimidating, game, LoSurdo advises you above all to relax.  "Just follow the basic rules of cooking. Boar’s in the pig family, so whatever you like to do with pork, do that, keeping in mind it’s going to have a stronger taste. I think what’s most important is to have a good time. If you make venison chops and they stink, you can always call a Chinese place.”

Bonus Tip: Perhaps inadvertently, the Ruth’s Chris Web site makes cooking a proper steak nearly as easy as booking a table at the restaurant. Check out the chophouse chain’s handy guide to deter-mining doneness at

Bonus Tip: John Dewar & Co.’s Web site ( also boasts a bounty of info for the eager amateur, from anatomical diagrams depicting the source of each cut to recipes and charts for such daunting dishes as standing rib roast, rack of lamb, and holiday turkey.

Eating it: from sides to sips

Morton's Scott Crain
Be it a humble home-cooked meal or a sumptuous steak-house spread, there’s more to a good chop dinner than the chops themselves. Take side dishes. For the most part  "they’re inter-changeable,"  as Jay Murray puts it — so it’s no faux pas to eschew the baked potato, creamed spinach, or grilled asparagus in favor of some-thing like the Met Club’s smashed sweet potato with brown sugar and pecans ($7) or Bonfire’s tempura green beans with truffle aioli ($6).

Meanwhile, Morton’s Scott Crain has some intriguing suggestions for lamb.  "Our caramelized onions with mushrooms are served in a kind of jus that’s intense with thyme, which is a very good flavor for lamb. We also just started serving mashed potatoes with a garlic butter made with anchovies and Pernod, which is an anise liqueur whose flavor accentuates what lamb is all about." Finally, he adds,  "I know it’s hard for people here to imagine, but we have an absolutely fantastic Australian rock-lobster tail. We serve ’em on the side, so you could do a different kind of surf-and-turf with lamb and rock lobster. "

As for wine, we have some refreshing news: the big reds are slowly loosening their strangle-hold on your steak dinner. Mind you, bold red wine with red meat is a classic pairing for good reason: as Crain puts it,  "tannins really accentuate the charred flavor of steak."  But there are equally good reasons to make other choices. Murray claims to prefer white wine as a counterbalance to the richness of steak.  "I like something with pretty crisp acidity, like a pinot gris or a riesling."  (By the same token, Murray implores diners who "are never going to get over"  their red fetish to at least try something  "brighter, like a grenache. You can’t get much brighter than that.")

LoSurdo concurs, using as an example his favorite Smith & Wollensky dish, the veal chop ($38), which is simply broiled and served with garlicky sauteed spinach and veal jus. "I like white wine with veal. I do. I like sauvignon blanc, chardonnay, pinot gris. In cooking school, they teach you about concentrating on finish when it comes to pairing. With something as soft as veal, a wine that lingers too long will take away from the flavor of the meat. But the finish of a wine like a sauvignon blanc is very crisp. And the crispness cuts right through the fat. That combination of crisp finish and fatty veal is great — [neither] takes away from the flavor of [the other]."  Asked about lamb, LoSurdo shrugs."  People say if you’re gonna have lamb, have pinot noir because it has the[requisite] fruit. It all goes back to finishing the palate  — and, in turn, polishing off that perfect pile of protein on your plate.

Bonus Tip: How does mushroom-chevre ravioli or ham-and-cheese gnocchi grab you? Grill 23’s Prime Beef Weekly Cuts Menu abounds with clever trimmings. Says Murray, "My dream when I introduced [the menu] was to get people to mix and match[cuts and sides], so they’d get to try ’em all in a way that they like."

Bonus Tip:  For a happy medium between bare-bones barbecue joints and budget-blowing steak houses, consider haunts like Tremont 647 and East Coast Grill, whose longevity may very well be chalked up to the celebrated grilling expertise of respective chef-owners Andy Husbands and Chris Schlesinger.

Latest Articles


North 26

A Jasper White protégé branches out with great success
I never call chefs before writing a review, but if I did speak with Brian Flagg of North 26, I'd ask him if Jasper White has ever paid a visit.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  September 30, 2009

Buddy's Truck Stop

That increasingly rare bird: the honest-to-goodness old-time diner
The modern truck stop typically sits in an interstate-adjacent service area with a parking lot that can accommodate scores of big rigs.
By MC SLIM JB  |  September 30, 2009

The Village Restaurant

Savoring the taste of Nigeria
I remember my click of recognition when I first saw a West African recipe for black-eyed-pea fritters with hot sauce, since my family in the South had always doused black-eyed peas with hot pepper sauce.
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  September 23, 2009

Community appeal

The Café at Pat's is a classic local spot
It is tricky to manage the transition from cult of personality to a rationalized institution.
By BRIAN DUFF  |  September 16, 2009

Saray Turkish Restaurant

Middle Eastern cuisine at its finest
Saray snuck in under my radar because the sign outside advertised halal meat.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  September 16, 2009


An old friend in new digs still slings an outstanding gyros sandwich
There are many reasons to silently mourn the closing of Filene's in Downtown Crossing, but I know I vociferously wailed at the accompanying evictions of several worthy take-out restaurants that operated at the famed department store's sidewalk level.
By MC SLIM JB  |  September 16, 2009

Junction Trattoria and Bistro

Peerless pizza and much more
On a recent rainy Friday evening, we were calling around for a place to eat dinner. One restaurant had no reservations till 9 pm (it's still tourist season); another was farther away than we'd realized, and we might end up eating at that same hour.
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  September 09, 2009
buffalo list

Late-night bites

It's dark. You're tired and hungry. You've come to the right place.
Yes, there are places in Portland to get something to eat after 10 pm — even as late as 3 am. From pizza and wings to pancakes and homemade apps, this city has your appetite covered, whether it's been a long night of Beirut or studying (ha!). We wouldn't want you to starve.
By ASHLEY RIGAZIO  |  August 26, 2009


A plea to kick up the heat
With visions of spices of the souk, we are apt to imagine that Moroccan food is as spicy as that of Mexico or Ethiopia.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  August 26, 2009

Franklin Spa

Friendly and flavorful by the sea
You know how some places just seem like they have a story behind them and you keep meaning to stop over the years but somehow it's never the right time of day (diner-type places mostly close by 2 pm)? That's been my relationship with Franklin Spa until I finally placed it squarely in my sights for a trip to Newport last week.
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  August 11, 2009
roti list

Ali's Roti Restaurant

A taste of Trinidadian love, with echoes of the Punjab
Watching folks eat at national fast-food outlets depresses me. Not only are they paying for advertising, but they're getting so little give-a-damn in their food. You sense that acutely after dining at a neighborhood place like Ali's Roti, a 22-seat counter-service Trinidadian restaurant at the western edge of the South End.
By MC SLIM JB  |  August 05, 2009
kinsale list


A little bit Irish, a little more 'whatever works'
"Take one spectacular location, season liberally with Norman, Spanish, and English influence, add one major battle and let it simmer for 400 years. The result — Ireland's fine food capital." So says the official tourist Web site of Kinsale, Ireland.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  September 14, 2009
estonian list

A long-ago farm

Exploring the origins of great food
Last week while you were reading here about Portland chef Krista Desjarlais's efforts at Bresca, I was cooking with her mother, Maili Kern, who lives in the West End. She taught me how to make rosolje, an incredible roast beef and root-vegetable salad from Estonia (recipe at ).
By LINDSAY STERLING  |  July 29, 2009

M and M Ribs

Back-yard barbecue made extraordinary by a seasoned pro
In America, there's barbecue, and then there's barbecue. For most of us, barbecue means direct, high-heat grilling over a gas flame or charcoal, the method used in most back yards. To the growing cult of authentic-barbecue aficionados, only slow, indirect cooking of meats using hardwood smoke at low temperatures (200 to 220 degrees Fahrenheit) is the real deal.
By MC SLIM JB  |  July 22, 2009

Max & Dylan's Kitchen & Bar

From the owners of Scollay Square, another fine bar-restaurant that does everything fairly well
Who is Max? Who is Dylan? The casual visitor cannot know. We know that the owners also have Scollay Square (which is not located in what used to be that square), so we have our suspicions that Max and Dylan are children or cats, or a confected evocation of the contrasting merits of ethnicity and cool.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  July 15, 2009

United BBQ

The pull of the pork, and so much more
Reviewing the dishes at a barbecue eatery feels a bit like judging a family dinner. Most of us have specific expectations of what the meats and the sides should taste like — sensory memories that grabbed us the first time we ate pulled pork or collard greens, and they won't let go.
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  July 08, 2009

Spiga Ristorante Italiano

A famed Boston chef moves to the 'burbs
I've had my eye on Spiga for a while — even though it is hard to keep an eye on a place tucked into a back street.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  July 08, 2009

St. Clair Annex

Seasonal delights in Watch Hill
Seasonal delights in Watch Hill
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  June 24, 2009

South End Pita

Even sandwich shops need a little time to grow up
Restaurant critics must perform a balancing act. We want to bring attention to worthy new places, but slagging a brand-new venue during its shakedown cruise for slow service or uneven kitchen output isn't really fair.
By MC SLIM JB  |  June 17, 2009

The Place

When only fancy will do
Sometimes a burger or a heap of nachos is just what the appetite (and budget) ordered. Sometimes nothing less than white linen elegance will do. A Newport place ambitiously named the Place bills itself as "the wine bar and grille at Yesterdays." The latter restaurant describes itself as "an alehouse;" it has 36 microbrews on tap and a menu that skews playful and Caribbean. Oy — a pint, mon.
By BILL RODRIGUEZ  |  June 17, 2009

Livin' la Vida Locavore

If farmers and artisans are packing their best goods and schlepping them to your 'hood, cheap, what's your excuse for not consuming them? 
Winter has always traumatized New Englanders, but because of the economy (thanks, rapacious mortgage-bundling douche bags!), this past season was particularly grim.
By SHAULA CLARK  |  June 10, 2009

Korean Garden Restaurant

Enjoy, we're here to help
Despite being open only six months, Korean Garden already has 22 Internet reviews.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  May 27, 2009

Los Andes

Back in delicious style
It makes sense that the people who run Los Andes are the ones who had a popular place further up Chalkstone for nine years. It was named simply the Bolivian Restaurant and was, in fact, pretty definitive. At a recent visit to the new restaurant, a fellow diner enthused that the baked saltinas (potato, yucca, and cheese), an indulgence-encouraging two-buck impulse purchase "at the Bolivian," were "worth driving across town for." Indeed.
By BILL RODRIGUEZ  |  May 20, 2009

Review: Off the Boat Seafood

Large portions, now served in a larger space
To find Off the Boat Seafood, a South Italian take-out joint that just this winter added a 10-table dining room and a wine list, mainlanders will pass through the Callahan Tunnel and embark on an exercise so challenging it's not unlike finding the Northwest Passage.
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  May 20, 2009

Trini's Mexican Grill

Splendid Mexican in a mall food court? ¡Absolutamente!
One of the joys of exploring Boston's cheap-eats universe is the occasional serendipitous encounter with an unlikely treasure.
By MC SLIM JB  |  May 20, 2009

The Local

New Newton favorite attempts less, achieves more
How many times have I reviewed fried calamari just in the last decade? Maybe 70, 80 times, right?
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  May 13, 2009
tried true list

Tried and true

Where to go for the ultimate summertime burgers
The greasy, informal meals of summer lead to lots of uncouth mouth-cramming and finger-licking. It is best not to look. For this reason, many purveyors of the quintessential summertime burger are set up for shoulder-to-shoulder eating.
By BRIAN DUFF  |  May 13, 2009

King Do Baguette and Pastry

An awesome roll makes for an extraordinary bánh mì
One measure of how far Americans have come in their globetrotting culinary breadth is the number of ordinary folks I know who've tried a bánh mì, the great Vietnamese street-food sandwich.
By MC SLIM JB  |  May 13, 2009

Flat Patties

Making a virtue of a usually guilt-ridden quickie
A fast-food cheeseburger is like a drunken assignation with a stranger met at a wedding reception: momentarily delectable but often leading to shame, nausea, and possibly even health issues.
By MC SLIM JB  |  May 06, 2009

Cosmic Steak, Pizza and Weiners

A Rhody landmark since 1977
A Rhody landmark since 1977
By JOHNETTE RODRIGUEZ  |  April 29, 2009

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group