TAKE TWO: The owners of the popular Washington Square Tavern simplify a successful formula with their second restaurant.

The original bread at the Washington Square Tavern was sourdough. The bread at the Beacon Street Tavern is dull French white bread. It still sops up some good sauces, but it’s a step down. Certainly the Maine lobster chowder ($8) is good, but is it chowder? The overwhelming flavors are heavily-smoked bacon and hot pepper. The broth offers little seafood sweetness, although there is lobster meat (and skin-on potatoes and celery) in the soup, and a no-thickener cream base.

Sashimi tuna tartare ($11) is also dominated by the seasonings, in this case soy and sesame so pervasive as to make it more like marinated ceviche than sashimi, which features the subtle flavors of plain raw fish. Again, this is good eating: tasty morsels of fish in the obligatory cylinder (ironically approaching the dimensions of a standard can of tuna fish), with a terrific side salad of arugula and three crisp fried triangles of wonton skin.

Most main dishes are served on oversize plates. If the plate is oval and somewhat standardized, it’s called a platter, as in sirloin tips ($15), with a choice of potato (choose mashed), and a well-dressed standard salad. The portions are generous and the meat is well marinated, probably with soy and garlic. If the plate is round, it’s an entrée. One of these, a special on veal Milanese ($23), had two slightly over-fried scaloppini over a nicely made creamy risotto (often a good choice at the Washington Square sibling) with bits of vegetables, including asparagus stirred in toward the end. The halibut ($23) is a vertical platter with a lively mango salsa over an over-salted crust on a fine light piece of fish, in turn resting on smoky flavored beans. The beans were fully cooked, which has become such a rare condition for shell beans in Boston that it is now worthy of notice. If you feel like more vegetables (and didn’t order the vegetarian entrée, a layered eggplant dish), you can add a side dish of something like broccolini ($3.50) for two or three people. Broccolini is like miniature broccoli, and therefore crunchier, but it also holds more garlic on each bite. I am in favor of this.

The wine list is lively and interesting, but the featured wines are rather expensive “second labels” of West Coast vintners. In the case of our glass of 2005 O’Reilly’s Pinot Noir ($8/glass; $32/bottle), this was not a winning strategy. I happen to have visited Oregon wineries this summer, and found that the promising pinot noirs that have developed there, mostly in the past 10 years, are so wildly overbought and overpriced that second-label wines are as soft and devoid of character as dating-bar merlot. The really good ones are often sold only as futures at the winery, and it’s hard to find even a notable bottle at less than $25 retail in Oregon. The Beacon Street Tavern didn’t even give this one a chance: it served an $8 wine in a 10-cent glass, a dishwasher-safe piece of stemware too small to contain both the wine and any aroma it might have developed.

What do I miss from the Washington Square Tavern? Primarily the variety of composed dishes on small plates, as well as the emphasis on the wood-fired oven. With a simplified menu served in a larger space, I take more notice of how few foods are presented with their natural flavors — pretty much only the halibut, and that after removing the salty crust. Everything else is marinated, smoky, very peppery, rather salty, maybe too garlicky (if that is possible), or otherwise more seasoned than not. It’s not wrong on the face of it, but a consistent un-blandness can be tiresome. And it must be said that this is the kind of food that really goes well with beer — this is a tavern, after all.

As at the Washington Square location, this tavern has no desserts. But once again, there is a good bakery nearby, so this is no disaster. The winning formula apparently includes the design, which is crucially dark. Repeat after me: “A tavern is always dark.” Well, not on summer evenings, but soon enough. Candles on the tables don’t give off much light either. The walls are dark-red, with some abstract paintings in brown and white, and much of the other detail is black. The floor, as at the old place, has quasi-Oriental carpets, which are accented by quasi-antique lamps.

Seating is at varied levels, from a long bar to the fashionably high table long enough for a board meeting, down to ordinary café tables. This makes a friendly tavern out of an over-large and hitherto difficult restaurant space.

The background music runs to blues and soul, and the crowd is young, but not exclusively so. Early on a weeknight, there were couples with babies taking advantage of the extensive outdoor seating. The inside gets loud, and it will only get louder when the outside crowd has to come indoors in cold weather.

A real strength for the Beacon Street Tavern is service, which is both quick out of the kitchen — despite the extra demands of outdoor seating — and friendly and helpful at the table. An oddity is that they refuse to sell take-out. The rationale given is that the chef doesn’t want people to judge his food after it travels. But they will pack up your leftovers for tomorrow’s lunch.

Beacon Street Tavern, 1032 Beacon Street, Brookline | daily, 5–11 pm | AE, MC, VI | full bar | no valet parking | sidewalk-level access | 617.713.2700

Email the author
Robert Nadeau: RobtNadeau@aol.com