The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In
 Explore Boston Phoenix coverage of SXSW Music Festival

Truth, Justice — or the Boston Way

Boston’s taxpayers just coughed up another multimillion-dollar check for a wrongful conviction, without being told what was done wrong
By DAVID S. BERNSTEIN  |  August 17, 2006

060818_cowans_color_main
STEPHAN COWANS: His wrongful conviction cost Boston taxpayers $3.2 million.
At 5pm on May 30, 1997, Stephan Cowans was sitting in a car, stuck in traffic with a friend on the way to doing some shopping in Cambridge.

At the same time, in a backyard on School Street Place in Roxbury, someone shot a Boston police officer, Gregory Gallagher, in the rear end with the officer’s own gun.

A year later, a Suffolk County prosecutor convinced a jury that Cowans was the shooter. The only problem was that the evidence, though compelling, was false. Cowans didn’t do it. Nevertheless, he spent six and a half years in prison for the crime.

Two years ago, Cowans was exonerated. The City of Boston recently paid him $3.2 million to settle claims that the police department violated his civil rights. And, under the terms of its wrongful-conviction compensation law, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts paid him an additional $500,000.

That does not mean Boston officials have acknowledged any wrongdoing, let alone accepted culpability. Indeed, the city asserted in its official legal defense that “the injuries and damages alleged” — i.e., the pain, suffering, humiliation, Hepatitis C, and loss of income, family relations, personal freedom, and sex life that Cowans endured in prison — “were caused by the Plaintiff’s own intentional conduct.” Apparently his wrongful conviction had nothing to do with it.

The Cowans case, along with 12 other wrongful Suffolk County convictions that came to light between 1999 and 2004, sparked reform and internal investigation in local law enforcement. The Boston Police Department (BPD) shut down and restarted from scratch the latent-fingerprint unit that the Cowans case revealed as woefully inadequate. The BPD and Suffolk County District Attorney’s office adopted a new set of guidelines for obtaining eyewitness identifications. Many of the officers involved in the Cowans investigation retired from the force. Attorney General Thomas Reilly investigated possible criminal charges against police officers.

And yet, Boston residents still don’t really know what led to the wrongful conviction of Stephan Cowans.

Civil lawsuits like Cowans’s help dredge up dirty details about the police department’s inner workings. But even these lawsuits are met with antagonism, secrecy, and, eventually, settlement to keep the case and its truths out of open court. The city has paid out $6.4 million of your tax money this year in wrongful-conviction suits, with at least two more substantial cases pending, and yet they have never told you why, or what really caused the wrongful convictions of Shawn Drumgold, Neil Miller, Donnell Johnson, Ulysses Rodriguez Charles, Anthony Powell, Marlon Passley, and others.

With the truth still buried, the only thing most people know about the Cowans case is that it forced Commissioner Kathleen O’Toole to shutter the BPD fingerprint unit in disgrace. The Cowans case did expose that unit’s incompetence, but in much the same way a banging noise in the basement can lead to the discovery of termites — a problem, to be sure, but not the one you’re looking for.

Not an accident
The lack of training, certification, or qualifications in the latent-print unit had little or nothing to do with Cowans’s conviction. That is the consensus of the BPD’s command staff, their internal investigators, and the outside forensics consultants they brought in to investigate the incident, as well as Suffolk District Attorney Dan Conley and Attorney General Tom Reilly.

1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |   next >
Related: Framed?, Righting a staggering wrong, More than a few loose ends, More more >
  Topics: News Features , Science and Technology, Criminal Sentencing and Punishment, Rosemary McLaughlin,  More more >
| More
Add Comment
HTML Prohibited

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 03/18 ]   American Repertory Theater  @ Cutler Majestic Theatre
[ 03/18 ]   Birdsong At Morning  @ First Congregational Church
[ 03/18 ]   Experimentally ILL 4  @ Somerville Theatre
More Information
A better use
Adding 70 police officers to the force, as Menino added to the city’s budget this year, will cost an estimated $2.6 million — less than what the city is paying Cowans for one wrongful conviction.
ARTICLES BY DAVID S. BERNSTEIN
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   CHINA SYNDROME  |  March 18, 2011
    Massachusetts has successfully jumped way out in front of every other state in the race for a share of the emerging trillion-dollar clean-energy market — which might end up meaning nothing, as the United States pisses away its chance to be part of that industry.  
  •   THE GOVERNOR IN HIS LABYRINTH  |  March 10, 2011
    Governor Deval Patrick has always excelled at inciting political speculation. Through his first three years in office, most Beacon Hill insiders remained convinced — even as his re-election effort began — that Patrick would not serve out his full four-year term.
  •   WILL WOMEN FIGHT BACK?  |  March 02, 2011
    Ominous headlines are dominating the news: revolution in the Middle East; surging gas prices; even a possible government shutdown.  Getting less attention, but with equally dire implications, is the concerted war against women being waged by Republicans.
  •   SIFTING FOR SUBSTANCE IN SCOTT BROWN'S MEMOIR  |  February 23, 2011
    Brown's memoir, Against All Odds , tells the inspiring rags-to-riches tale of how one can rise from terrible circumstances to great power and influence, with just a little hard work, perseverance, supermodel good looks and world-class athletic ability.
  •   MITT REWRITES HIMSELF  |  February 11, 2011
    When Mitt Romney's second book, No Apology , came out a year ago, it looked like he was moving away from the far-right demagoguery of his 2008 bid for the presidency, and toward a more moderate centrism for the 2012 election cycle. But times change, and so does Mitt.

 See all articles by: DAVID S. BERNSTEIN

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 



  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
thePhoenix.com:
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group