CD Reviews

Miley Cyrus

Breakout | Hollywood

By DANIEL BROCKMAN | August 4, 2008

2.5 Stars

Some records are bold and unconfusing statements of purpose — but in the world of teen pop, hindsight has often shown that what at first seemed like frothy shallow little ditties are desperately coded missives from a sad soul wailing behind a wall of synthetic beats and chilled hearts. When Ms. Cyrus, on her oh-so-inappropriate cover of Cyndi Lauper’s “Girls Just Want To Have Fun,” sings, “My father yells/‘Whatcha gonna do with your life?’,” you can hear a world-weary terror at odds with the cut-loose pillow fight of the original. In Miley’s rendition of the title line, there’s a difference between wanting to have fun and actually having it. Glossed to a shine by the same crew behind No Doubt’s Tragic Kingdom, Breakout is a puzzling mishmash that makes sense only if you read between the lines and see the 15-year-old trapped in a machine that is partly of her own design. If you can get over the flagrant missteps (the less said about “Wake Up America,” the better), there’s some pretty rad stuff here. “Fly on the Wall” is a metallic Stefani-sassing electro-slamming plea for privacy — a bratty, defiant, and bizarre middle finger to the world that created her. Someday, one hopes, Ms. Cyrus and her therapists will go back and analyze this platter and everything will make much more sense.

Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds Concert Tour in Disney Digital 3-D
Oodles of fun
Sugarland
Love on the Inside | Mercury Nashville
The kids in the hall
Teen pregnancies are up. Can on-campus student-parent services be far behind?
More

Topics: CD Reviews , Miley Cyrus , Miley Cyrus , Cyndi Lauper , More

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY DANIEL BROCKMAN

DIRT MERCHANTS | September 16, 2008
Farm Aid crops up in Massachusetts

PRESERVED JAM | September 16, 2008
Paul Weller at Berklee Performance Center, September 9, 2008

ANNIE | September 16, 2008
Don’t Stop | Island

SHREDDING ZOO | September 09, 2008
Extreme rock the New York State Fair

THROWBACK THROWDOWN | September 09, 2008
Magic Christian at the Middle East Upstairs, September 6, 2008

See all articles by: DANIEL BROCKMAN

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

BAD CRAZINESS
Wall Street’s meltdown is more dangerous than realized. McCain is clueless, but does Obama recognize the root of the problem?

APPALOOSA
Unexpected and rewarding despite conventional scenarios

DAVID FOSTER WALLACE — 1962–2008
Overhead baggage

PHOTOS: BOSTON FASHION WEEK 2008
Lingerie on the runway and more

WINGED FEET
Dance around town

WINDOWS
In her new memoir, When I Grow Up , Boston icon Juliana Hatfield comes clean about her depression, and why Wal-Mart would have been blamed for her suicide