CD Reviews

The Breeders

Mountain Battles | 4AD

By MICHAEL BRODEUR | April 29, 2008

2.5 Stars

A big part of maintaining a lasting, fruitful relationship with the Breeders is acceptance. You’re not going to get too far pining for Josephine Wiggs or Tanya Donnelly or that drummer with the serious tube socks to show up again. By now it’s unrealistic to expect vestigial Pixies characteristics, and it’s downright unfair to demand the same feather-light rasp from Kim Deal’s chimney. In other words, there will be no future Pod, and Last Splash was just that. The uncertainty of sound and spirit that characterized 2002’s Title TK is still palpable — but that’s not to shortchange uncertainty. If anything, this time around, the Breeders sound more comfortable with no prescription (no mean jab intended); when Kim Deal diversifies her portfolio with the Spanish-sung “Regálame Esta Noche,” or the (you guessed it) German-sung “German Studies,” or the ecstatically repetitive opener, “Overglazed,” or the porchy hoedown of “Here No More,” it often amounts to silly, albeit highly satisfying, dabblings. It’s reasonable, given the variety of their back catalogue, to hope that the Breeders never commit to any given motif — but there’s a fine line between a fearless band testing several fresh approaches and a piecemeal album that has you longing for the glories of “Glorious.”

loudQuietloud: A Film About The Pixies
A must-see for fans
Raw deals
The Breeders at the Paradise, June 5, 2008
Documentary evidence
Three DVDs capture the Pixies’ reunion
More

Topics: CD Reviews , Kim Deal , THE BREEDERS , Tanya Donnelly

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY MICHAEL BRODEUR

MIXED, NUTS | October 15, 2008
The Mad Decent tour hits Boston

MOLTEN ’CORE | October 08, 2008
The triumphant return of Shudder To Think

GROOP THERAPY | October 01, 2008
Stereolab do it again for the first time

NEW KIDS ON THE BLOCK | September 23, 2008
Allow Dear Leader to introduce you

ALL TOMORROW’S PARTIES II | September 25, 2008
Edan at Kutshers Country Resort, Monticello, New York, September 19-21, 2008

See all articles by: MICHAEL BRODEUR

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

SCHLEPPING FOR OBAMA
The Boston roots of Sarah Silverman's Jewbama crusade

I HAD AN ABORTION
Forty percent of American women have abortions by the time they're 45. I'm one of them.

OLD TRICKSTER
At age 78, able-bodied Alan Abel’s life is still one big joke

BULL DISCLOSURE
As the candidates prep for the final debate, it’s a fitting time to ask: why do some journalistic conflicts of interest become scandals, while others get almost no attention at all?

THE MELTING POT
Dip into confusing dining

SCHLEPPING FOR OBAMA
The Boston roots of Sarah Silverman's Jewbama crusade

WORDS AS MUSIC
Alan Lupo was many things — among them, the best metro columnist Boston may ever see

PHOTOS: RISD'S CHACE CENTER
Images from Rhode Island School of Design's new museum

BULL DISCLOSURE
As the candidates prep for the final debate, it’s a fitting time to ask: why do some journalistic conflicts of interest become scandals, while others get almost no attention at all?