CD Reviews

Joni Mitchell

Shine | Hear Music

By JEFF TAMARKIN | November 6, 2007

2.5 Stars

Joni Mitchell’s first album for Starbucks’ Hear Music label isn’t being hyped as a concept album, but that’s what it is. Almost every song wags a finger at the impending environmental apocalypse, rampant political evils, and those who would allow such badness to thrive. Hopeful glimmers —“Hana,” a stoic call for volunteerism and keeping the faith — cut through the gloom, but Mitchell’s not making any long-term plans. “We have poisoned everything and oblivious to it all/The cellphone zombies babble through the shopping malls,” she sings in “Bad Dreams.” The title song rails against both “Frankenstein technologies” and “assholes passing on the right,” among other modern-day bummers; even the remake of “Big Yellow Taxi” takes on a discomforting 11th-hour hue absent from the original. Mitchell produced the album and played most of the instruments (including the cheesy disco-era drum machine). The arrangements are stark and lean, relying on ominous, droning washes of ambient sound, subtle jazzy guitar and keyboard, well-placed sax bursts, and honeyed pedal steel to provide coloring. Subdued but not entirely resigned, Mitchell sings in a strong, assured voice that’s still warm and welcoming, though lowered by decades of ecologically unhip tobacco smoke. Closing with “If,” with lyrics adapted from Rudyard Kipling, she assures, “I know you’ll be all right.” Then again, maybe not.

Related: Beginning? Or end?, Beginning? Or end?, Herbie Hancock, More

Beginning? Or end?
Let me get this straight up front: I didn't go to Woodstock. But I was teaching a "student-initiated course" in pop-music history at Antioch College at the time, and a number of my students announced that they were going to miss a couple of classes because they had tickets to Woodstock.
Beginning? Or end?
Let me get this straight up front: I didn't go to Woodstock. But I was teaching a "student-initiated course" in pop-music history at Antioch College at the time, and a number of my students announced that they were going to miss a couple of classes because they had tickets to Woodstock.
Herbie Hancock
Herbie isn’t fooling around — the guest stars are here, yes, but Hancock is stretching out, with languid, meditative takes on the Mitchell songbook.
Various Artists: Wayfaring Strangers: Ladies from the Canyon
Who’d have guessed we’d live to see a revival of the ’70s female singer-songwriter?
Praise the Lord
This article originally appeared in the March 13, 1993 issue of the Boston Phoenix.
Three for the road
Maybe it’s Larry Klein’s world and the rest of us just live in it.
ID Check: Casey Dienel
A 21-year-old Scituate songbird signed to the Decemberists' old label is about to sing her Massachusetts song.
Mind boggling
The article “ Rethinking 9/11 ” offered some provocative, well-written food for thought. But what I ultimately found most “mind bending” was that you could run a piece like this without including the voice of a single Muslim or Arab.
Cover girls
On Cat Power’s second album of covers, she might be traveling the same territory Elvis did in “Kentucky Rain” — a country road with low clouds on a chill, gray afternoon.
Prime time
To many political conservatives during Vietnam, championing the music of Bob Dylan, Pete Seeger, and Joni Mitchell was the equivalent of French-kissing Chairman Mao.
Happy endings
The end is nigh! And I’m not talking about the mortgage market.
Less

Topics: CD Reviews , Entertainment, Music, Music Reviews, More

Comments

Add a Comment

Best Music Poll 2009 winners

Today's Event Picks

[FILM] “RiffTrax Live” 2009 presents: Plan 9 from Outer Space

Plus 3 more >>

--> -->

ARTICLES BY JEFF TAMARKIN

GEORGE THOROGOOD | THE DIRTY DOZEN | July 22, 2009
Before you press PLAY, you know what you're going to get on The Dirty Dozen : music to drink lots of beer by.

SON VOLT | AMERICAN CENTRAL DUST | July 15, 2009
With American Central Dust , Jay Farrar has now accomplished something he was unable to do either during Son Volt's initial run (1995-99) or his evidently aborted solo career (2001-04): released three consecutive albums of undeniable quality.

DAVID BOWIE | STORYTELLERS | July 07, 2009
Bowie was particularly relaxed and reflective when he took his star turn on VH1's Storytellers program 10 years ago next month.

ELVIS COSTELLO | SECRET, PROFANE AND SUGARCANE | June 08, 2009
There are few genres into which Elvis Costello hasn't delved over the years, but he's always seemed particularly comfortable within the traditional back-porch country that occupies this latest session.

GREEN DAY | 21ST CENTURY BREAKDOWN | June 01, 2009
If anyone had suggested, circa Dookie 15 years ago, that Green Day would one day carry the torch for the classic rock opera . . . well, no one would have.

See all articles by: JEFF TAMARKIN

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

WHOLE FOODS HEALTH-CARE BOYCOTT GATHERS MOMENTUM
Unfortunately for Whole Foods Market CEO and founder John Mackey, those who appreciate his store for the healthy, eco-friendly (read: left-leaning, progressive) lifestyle it promotes are the same citizens who support universal health care.

PLAYERS ONLY
Jessica Smith has spent years booking death-metal shows around Boston. On top of loads of meat-and-potatoes nights at O'Brien's in Allston and Dee Dee's in Quincy, two of her shows — Origin and Malevolent Creation — actually sold out the Middle East upstairs.

REVIEW: INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
From the beginning, Tarantino's obsessive self-referentiality and movie allusions never let you forget that you're watching a film.

WHY WIND POWER BLOWS
The world is looking for a no-brainer solution to the 21st century's impending energy crisis, and wind power seems to provide many of the right answers.

DEFAMING TWITTER
Hate Twitter? Then you're probably loving a new, buzz-generating study — released last week by the Texas market-research firm Pear Analytics — which found that the vast majority of Twitter messages, a/k/a tweets, are pretty much worthless.

WHOLE FOODS HEALTH-CARE BOYCOTT GATHERS MOMENTUM
Unfortunately for Whole Foods Market CEO and founder John Mackey, those who appreciate his store for the healthy, eco-friendly (read: left-leaning, progressive) lifestyle it promotes are the same citizens who support universal health care.

A MIGHTY WIND
This past Earth Day, President Barack Obama, speaking at an Iowa wind-turbine factory, delivered a gusty peroration. "The nation that leads the world in creating new energy sources will be the nation that leads the 21st-century global economy," he said. "America can be that nation. America must be that nation."

WHY WIND POWER BLOWS
The world is looking for a no-brainer solution to the 21st century's impending energy crisis, and wind power seems to provide many of the right answers.

PLAYERS ONLY
Jessica Smith has spent years booking death-metal shows around Boston. On top of loads of meat-and-potatoes nights at O'Brien's in Allston and Dee Dee's in Quincy, two of her shows — Origin and Malevolent Creation — actually sold out the Middle East upstairs.