Reviews

Milarepa: Magician, Murderer, Saint

Plays like a Wikipedia page

By NICK MCCARTHY | October 3, 2007

1.0 Stars

MILAREPA: Mountains, monks, and wailing women, but not the teachings of Milarepa.

All mountains, monks, and a soundtrack of wailing women, Neten Chokling’s film opens with the announcement of a birth. The father of this child exclaims, “This is joyful news!”, and he names the child Thopa Ga, which the subtitle translates as “joyful news.” Thus begins Chokling’s interpretation of the most inspirational saint in Tibet’s history. Although it’s believed that Thopa Ga, who will later become known as Milarepa, faced adversity throughout his life, there’s no sense of suffering here beyond the tiny amount of dirt that accumulates on his face. Despite a photogenic landscape, Milarepa plays like a Wikipedia page, with Chokling using Thopa Ga’s timeline as a cinematic checklist. Trite words of wisdom are scattered throughout the pedantry, the most repeated being “Don’t look back.” Good advice to the viewer, since this simplistic version of Milarepa’s life and teachings against greed and violence leaves little to reflect on.

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY NICK MCCARTHY

NEVER FOREVER | May 21, 2008
Sulky and not believable

ROMAN DE GARE | May 16, 2008
Don't be fooled into thinking this film has substance

BLINDSIGHT | March 12, 2008
Courage and naïveté

GRACE IS GONE | January 23, 2008
No catharsis here, just soft piano keys

MILAREPA: MAGICIAN, MURDERER, SAINT | October 03, 2007
Plays like a Wikipedia page

See all articles by: NICK MCCARTHY

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

INTERVIEW: AMANDA PALMER
At home with the Dresden Doll's solo joint

PHOTOS: WEEZER AT TSONGAS ARENA
Weezer at Tsongas Arena, Lowell, MA, September 23, 2008

TWITHEADS
Is it time to dial down journalism’s latest fad?

BLUNT OBJECT
The political fight over a November marijuana-reform ballot question has sparked a Battle of the Bong

THE BIG HURT: HAGAR THE HORRIBLE
Plus award-winning awards and buggering Beatles

ARE UNIVERSITIES SELLING OUT TO OIL NATIONS?
As big bucks beckon, Gulf campuses of American universities are booming

PERSONALLY SPEAKING
Abortion and Life tells whole truths

TWITHEADS
Is it time to dial down journalism’s latest fad?

BROOKLINE FAMILY RESTAURANT’S DÖNER KEBAB
Meat the family

PHOTOS: WEEZER AT TSONGAS ARENA
Weezer at Tsongas Arena, Lowell, MA, September 23, 2008

HOT TOPICS

Daniel Day-Lewis , Jack Black , Michael Clayton , Michael Haneke , Osama bin Laden , Massachusetts Institute of Technology , Michael Jackson , Paris Hilton , Paul Thomas Anderson , Tommy Lee Jones

Reviews

Milarepa: Magician, Murderer, Saint

The Best 2008

Masters of Muppets

Maneaters: A history

Political cartoons

Potter-schmotter!