If Obama really had guts, he would have a press conference that goes something like this:

By Harvey Silverglate, 

My wife and I wish to commend the staff of The New Yorker. They have finally realized that the level of political rhetoric in this country has fallen so low that the only appropriate response is satire. There is no way that I could have possibly responded to my critics and detractors as effectively as has the artist who drew that cover. It demonstrates once again that a picture is worth more than a thousand words. 

                I’ve been unable to convince the nation that I am not a Muslim, for one thing. Now, mind you, I would not feel ashamed if I were a Muslim. It would be a sad day in America if citizens have to be ashamed of their religious beliefs and affiliations. But my hidden critics and enemies are seeking to ‘tar’ me with the brush of being a Muslim. And somehow that rumor takes on a life of its own. I hesitate to even deny it, because one should be proud to be a Muslim in America, much as Catholics are proud, Protestants are proud, Jews are proud, Buddhists are proud, Scientologists are proud – but you get the point. However, facts and truth seem not to matter in the realm of the Political Attack Machine, or perhaps I should call it the Hate Machine.

And this Hate Machine spares not even my better half. Vile whispers have cast Michelle as a modern-day 1960s black radical, carrying with her the racial hatred that any sensible person would have long ago rejected.  Will my children be the next objects of these attack dogs? We can only hold our breath and wait and see.

                So when unreality begins to take over reality, and truth and facts cease to matter, our only effective remaining weapons are satire and parody. My wife would never carry an AK-47 assault rifle, just as she would never carry the racial hostility so readily placed upon her shoulders. I would never burn an American flag (although I believe that such burning is and should continue to be constitutionally protected by our First Amendment), but a lack of lapel pins signals, to some, a “lack of patriotism.” Sadly, such is the reality of our political culture in 2008. Far from advancing racist ideology, The New Yorker has well served the national dialogue by, at long last, exposing the ludicrous – and evil – underbelly of the Hate Machine. 

If you want to understand the importance of parody and satire in the life of a free nation, you cannot do better than to sit down and read the Supreme Court’s unanimous 1987 opinion in the historic case of Hustler v. Falwell, found at 485 U.S. 46. It was written, interestingly, by the late Chief Justice William Rehnquist, not always a friend to freedom. But in the realm of protection of satire and parody as an essential method by which social and political evils may be effectively exposed and criticized, the justices were unanimous in joining the Rehnquist opinion. In that case, the justices ruled that the First Amendment protected Hustler Magazine’s vicious parody directed at the now-deceased Reverend Jerry Falwell. Hustler publisher Larry Flynt suggested that the good reverend experienced his first sexual encounter in a drunken orgy with his mother in an outhouse. Not only was this vicious satire deemed constitutionally protected, but the court went on to review the importance of satire and parody in the American political discourse from the very earliest days of the founding of the Republic. Many of the satires and parodies that helped advance American political life were as or more biting even than The New Yorker’s well-crafted assault on my and my wife’s cowardly whispering critics who spread anonymous rumors rather than announce their lies openly.

Long live satire! Long live parody! Long live truth! May God bless you all, and our beloved United States of America which, I have the duty to advise you, is in some trouble if The New Yorker suffers for telling the truth with such moral clarity and, even more importantly, good humor.  

And, oh yes, one more thing: Please remember to vote!


| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular 
All Blogs
Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
Search Blogs
Free For All Archives